TaxVox Tariff Repeal Options Would Have Very Different Price Effects
John Wong, Robert McClelland
Display Date

Concerns over high prices dominated the midterm election. The next Congress may consider tariff repeal as a way to respond. For example:

  • Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) identified eliminating tariffs on Canadian goods imposed under Section 338 of the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 as a potential area for bipartisan action.
  • Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) introduced the End Trump’s Tariff Tax Act, which would repeal two presidential tariff authorities: Section 338 and Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974. The bill would also eliminate tariffs relating to forced labor imposed under Section 301 of the 1974 law.
  • Reps. Don Beyer (D-VA) and Suzan DelBene (D-WA) introduced the Congressional Trade Authority Act of 2025, which would repeal tariffs imposed under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 dating back to the first Trump administration (unless explicitly approved by Congress). The bill would also require congressional approval for future actions.

TPC examines four options for rolling back tariffs. These range from only repealing tariffs imposed under Section 338 to also eliminating some or all Section 301 tariffs, with additional options that would also repeal Section 232 tariffs.

The estimated economic effects of the levels of repeal vary considerably. TPC finds that repealing Section 338 tariffs alone would reduce families' average federal tax burden by just $30 in 2027, but eliminating tariffs imposed under all three authorities would reduce that burden by an estimated $1,130 (Figure 1).

FIGURE 1

 
Section 338 tariffs apply narrowly on Canadian goods

The Section 338 tariffs apply a 50 percent rate to a sliver of Canadian-origin imports, covering only about 0.5 percent of global imports. TPC estimates repealing these narrowly applied tariffs would reduce the average tariff rate from 10.1 percent to 9.8 percent—a mere 0.3 of a percentage point (Figure 2).

FIGURE 2

Under specific assumptions, TPC can estimate how prices respond to tariff changes (Figure 3, Notes). TPC finds the effect of repealing Section 338 on prices would be less than 0.05 percent—effectively zero.

FIGURE 3

 
Section 301’s forced labor tariff applies broadly in 60 countries

Section 301 grants the United States Trade Representative (USTR) the authority to initiate investigations and subsequent trade actions. Prior to the second Trump administration, this authority had largely been used to impose successive tariffs on Chinese-origin goods after investigations into technology transfer. In 2025 the Trump administration expanded the process to target more countries after the Supreme Court invalidated tariffs imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act and temporary Section 122 tariffs expired.

A USTR investigation of forced labor practices culminated in a tariff on goods from 60 countries, including members of the European Union and Norway. The tariff covers about 22 percent of all imports.

A second option, repealing the forced labor Section 301 tariff and Section 338, would reduce the average tariff rate to 7.4 percent—a decline of an additional 2.4 percentage points. TPC estimates that overall prices would fall 0.3 percent, and that tax burdens would fall by an average of $420.

All Section 301 tariffs include China, Brazil, and Nicaragua

A third option is repealing Section 338 and all Section 301 tariffs, including those on Chinese-origin goods imposed for technology transfer and maritime dominance, Brazil for various issues, and Nicaragua for labor and human rights abuses and erosion of the rule of law. This option would reduce prices by 0.4 percent. The price decrease is most prominent in furniture and electronic goods. The tax burden would fall by an average of $540 per family.

Section 232 tariffs cover the most, including metals, vehicles, and more

Section 232 allows the president to adjust imports based on the Commerce Secretary’s recommendations. This authority has allowed duties on metals, semiconductors, cars, trucks, wood, drugs, and other goods. These tariffs cover 21 percent of all imports.

A fourth option, repealing Section 232 along with Section 338 and Section 301 tariffs, could cut the average tariff rate to 1.2 percent, an additional five percentage points. This option would reduce prices by 0.7 percent. The price drop would be most prominent in furniture and electronics, but also in machinery, vehicles, car parts, and computers—industrial inputs whose higher costs spread through the domestic supply chain. This would translate to a $1,130 average reduction in a family’s tax burden.

Other trade remedies would remain available

Proponents of tariffs argue that the federal government needs the ability to protect domestic industries or fight “dumping,” which occurs when a foreign producer sells its product to US importers at a much lower price than it would charge in its own market. Remaining tariff authorities protect that ability.

If trade agencies’ investigators, empowered to travel to accused countries and seek detailed records, find unfair trading practices, those agencies can impose antidumping and countervailing duties (AD/CVD). Separately, Section 201 of the Trade Act of 1974 allows the president to impose tariffs if the International Trade Commission finds that a domestic industry is or could be injured by an import surge.

Whatever avenue Congress ultimately pursues, TPC’s findings illustrate how the economic consequences of repeal depend on which and how many tariff authorities lawmakers choose to address.

Tags tariffs tariff
Primary topic Tariffs
Research Area Tariffs